Occupational physician and labour expert: who decides what?

Meta Marzguioui - de Zeeuw7 April 2026Updated on 9 November 2026
Illustration of a doctor in a white coat taking notes on a clipboard, next to a medical report

The occupational physician establishes what a sick employee can do medically, and the labour expert translates that into work. The occupational physician describes the employee’s work capacity and advises on recovery and return to work. The labour expert takes that work capacity as the starting point and assesses which work inside or outside the organisation is suitable. If their advice conflicts, neither overrules the other: you ask for clarification, a second opinion or an expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel) from UWV.

This article explains how that division of roles works, when the occupational physician recommends a labour expert assessment, what exactly the labour expert takes over and what to do when the two pieces of advice do not fit together.

Who does what: the occupational physician or the labour expert?

The occupational physician is the only expert an employer is required to involve when an employee is sick. Under article 14 of the Working Conditions Act, the occupational physician advises on the guidance of employees who cannot work because of illness. The occupational physician assesses the medical situation and describes what someone can and cannot do: how many hours, what kind of strain, what pace.

A labour expert looks at the work. Can the employee still do their own job, can that job be adapted, and which other positions fit the described work capacity? UWV’s Werkwijzer Poortwachter describes the labour expert as an expert the employer and employee can bring in, but are not required to.

In short:

  • Occupational physician: establishes work capacity, gives a prognosis and advises on recovery and return to work.
  • Labour expert: compares that work capacity with the demands of positions and advises on suitable work, adjustments and the choice between track 1 and track 2.
  • Employer and employee: include the advice in the plan of action and remain jointly responsible for reintegration.

When does the occupational physician recommend a labour expert assessment?

The first formal step is the problem analysis. The occupational physician draws it up no later than week 6 of the absence. According to the Werkwijzer, it covers not only medical factors but also education, skills, the employee’s own job and other circumstances that affect the absence. The problem analysis contains advice on how the possibilities for recovery and return to work can be used. No later than week 8, the employer and employee draw up the plan of action on that basis, with input from a labour expert where needed.

Article 7a of the Regeling procesgang eerste en tweede ziektejaar also places a duty on the occupational physician: if additional expertise is needed for proper reintegration, the occupational physician makes sure it is brought in on time. In practice, the occupational physician mainly recommends a labour expert assessment when:

  • the employee has lasting limitations and a return to their own job is uncertain;
  • the work capacity is stable enough to translate into work;
  • it is unclear which adjustments or other positions are possible within the organisation;
  • the employer and employee disagree about what suitable work is.

Other signals and moments that play a role are covered in when a labour expert assessment is needed. For the usual assessment around the end of the first year of sickness, see the assessment after one year of sickness.

What does the labour expert use from the occupational physician’s advice?

The labour expert adopts the work capacity as the occupational physician describes it and does not reassess it. The Werkwijzer is clear about this: what the personal profile says about limitations must be based on what the occupational physician has stated. A plan for track 2 must take the occupational physician’s prognosis into account as far as possible.

In concrete terms, the labour expert uses:

  • the description of functional abilities, often in the form of an employability profile (IZP);
  • any limitation on working hours and the expected build-up;
  • the prognosis: will the work capacity still change, and within what period;
  • the advice from the problem analysis and later updates.

The occupational physician does not have to draw up a Functional Abilities List (FML) for this. According to the Werkwijzer, the FML is a UWV instrument; the occupational physician describes work capacity in comparable terms. Medical data do not belong in the labour expert’s report. The labour expert works with what someone can do, not with the diagnosis.

If the medical situation changes, the occupational physician updates the problem analysis. The employer must then inform any reintegration agency involved straight away, because the programme has to match the new work capacity.

What if the occupational physician and the labour expert disagree?

A conflict between the two usually concerns one of three things: the work capacity is too vague to translate into work, the work capacity does not match what the employee shows in practice, or the parties disagree about what suitable work is. The approach differs per situation.

The work capacity is unclear or does not seem right. The labour expert does not set a new work capacity. The question goes back to the occupational physician, with a concrete description of what is unclear. The occupational physician can then update or explain the problem analysis.

The employee doubts the occupational physician’s advice. The employee can request a second opinion from another occupational physician. Under article 14 of the Working Conditions Act, the occupational physician grants such a request unless there are serious objections.

The employer and employee disagree about suitable work or the efforts made. Either of them can then request an expert opinion from UWV. For an opinion on suitable work, UWV asks for, among other things, the occupational physician’s reports on work capacity and the labour expert’s report.

As an employer, you cannot hide behind incorrect advice later. According to the Werkwijzer, the occupational physician and other experts you bring in work under your responsibility. Incorrect advice is therefore not a valid reason if UWV finds the reintegration inadequate, with a wage sanction as a possible result.

When is an expert opinion from UWV useful?

An expert opinion is independent advice from UWV. According to UWV, you can request one on whether the employee can do their own job, whether other work is suitable, and whether the employer or employee is doing enough for reintegration. The opinion is not binding, but the Werkwijzer expects the employer and employee to take it to heart. When UWV later reviews the reintegration report, it does not in principle deviate from an earlier expert opinion, unless that opinion proves to be clearly wrong.

UWV has waiting times and screens requests first. According to its Handreiking deskundigenoordelen, requests involving a dispute get priority. So do not wait until just before the WIA application. How to prepare a request is explained in requesting an expert opinion from UWV.

What does this mean for the start of track 2?

How the occupational physician and the labour expert work together often determines when track 2 begins. According to the Werkwijzer, track 2 starts as soon as there is no longer any prospect of a structural return within the employee’s own organisation, and no later than six weeks after the first-year evaluation, which takes place between week 46 and week 52. The only exception is a concrete prospect of return within three months.

An expectation of recovery from the occupational physician is therefore no reason to postpone track 2 indefinitely. If the work capacity is stable and the labour expert concludes that there is no suitable work internally, track 2 should start at that point.

How Care4Careers helps

Care4Careers arranges labour expert assessments and guides employees in track 2. In a track 2 programme, the established work capacity and the labour expert assessment are the starting point for the search profile. If the work capacity changes, we adjust the programme accordingly. A programme takes 3 to 12 months and costs between €2,300 and €7,500, depending on its duration, content and intensity. The employer and employee receive a monthly progress report that you can use in the reintegration file.

This explanation is general and does not replace occupational health or legal advice. For your own situation, always check UWV’s current Werkwijzer Poortwachter.

Want to know whether a labour expert assessment makes sense in your situation? Request a labour expert assessment and we will get in touch.

Frequently asked questions about the occupational physician and the labour expert assessment

Does the occupational physician have to recommend a labour expert assessment before you can have one?

No. The employer and employee can bring in a labour expert themselves. Under the Regeling procesgang eerste en tweede ziektejaar, however, the occupational physician must make sure additional expertise is brought in on time when it is needed. If the occupational physician recommends a labour expert, you record that in the plan of action and follow it up.

Can the labour expert deviate from the work capacity set by the occupational physician?

No, the labour expert does not make medical judgements. If the labour expert sees that the described work capacity does not match what works in practice, or is too vague to translate into work, the question goes back to the occupational physician. Only the occupational physician can adjust the work capacity.

Does the labour expert get my medical information?

That is not necessary. The labour expert works with a functional description of what you can and cannot do, without a diagnosis. The Werkwijzer Poortwachter also states that the problem analysis sent to the employer contains no medical data.

Does the occupational physician have to draw up an FML?

No. The Functional Abilities List (FML) is a UWV instrument. According to the Werkwijzer Poortwachter, the occupational physician describes work capacity in comparable terms, for example in an employability profile (Inzetbaarheidsprofiel, IZP), but does not have to provide an FML.

Can the employer rely on incorrect advice from the occupational physician before UWV?

Usually not. The occupational physician works under the employer's responsibility. According to the Werkwijzer Poortwachter, incorrect advice from an expert the employer brought in is therefore not a valid reason for inadequate reintegration. If you doubt a piece of advice, have it reviewed in good time.

Part ofOccupational assessment

Sources

The legal statements in this article are based on the sources below. Legislation changes; always check the current text for your own situation.

About the author

Meta Marzguioui - de Zeeuw, program designer & project lead bij Care4Careers

Meta Marzguioui - de Zeeuw

Program Designer & Project Lead

With over 30 years of experience in HR, project management, and career development, I enjoy working at the intersection of strategy and implementation, always balancing organizational goals with human perspective.

View profile
Share this article

Contact

Fill in this form for more information about our services.
‍
Or register yourself or an employee for one of our services.

Head office
Care4Careers B.V.
Eigenhaardweg 8
7811 LR Emmen

View all our locations